Enter Page Title Here
Income
Trusts - What's Next ?
Friday,
November 10, 2006. Toronto. Finance minister Jim Flaherty's
announcement to phase out the income trusts tax advantages made on Oct 31st will
divide the history of investment industry into two time periods. Pre
Oct 31st 2006 and Post Oct 31 2006. This announcement was expected due
to the following:
1. There are about 250 income trusts
trading on TSX and annual governmental tax losses have reached $500 million
already.
2. Only 70 trusts were listed on TSX in 2000 and by 2006 this
numbed had climbed to 250.
3. If Bell
Canada and Telus were to complete their
trust conversions, it would have marked as the largest in
Canada and government would have lost $1.1
billion annually in tax revenue.
4. Every major company would follow
the trend because of their obligation to maximize shareholder value. Such as
companies like banks, insurance companies, oil and gas companies... basically
everyone.
5. Countries like
America and
Australia have already got rid of income
trusts already.
The tax burden of average
Canadians has sky rocketed over the last 25 years and on the other hand, the tax
burden of corporations has gone down significantly. Ordinary Canadians have been
asked to carry more and more tax burden every year. The principal benefactors of
trusts were not ordinary Canadians but high net worth individuals and
non-resident investors and institutional investors. Ordinary investors who only
invest in mutual funds and stocks will not notice any significant change in
their portfolios due to this new tax ruling. Investors who have a few hundred
thousands and more sitting in income trusts will be affected most.
Government should take
steps to stop inequality in taxations. Taxes on capital gains and dividends
should be eliminated or reduced. Double taxations hurt ordinary investors and it
discourages people to invest. Hopefully tax savings from this announcement will
be used on social programs and also government will look at the prospect of
reducing the tax burden of average Canadians and average investors who are being
taxed on dividends and capital gains. Ordinary investors, like myself, can't
help but ask why the trusts have not yet been phased out of the Canadian markets
like they have been in the US, and why took so long to put an end to this unfair
advantage if it has never been a good thing for our country?